Beyond Financials: The Key HR Strategies for M&A Success

Sherry Godin MBA, CHRP shared this article

Authored by 

Published

ARTICLE | October 24, 2024


Beyond Financials: The Key HR Strategies for M&A Success

Introduction

Mergers and acquisitions (M&A) are powerful tools that organizations use to accelerate growth, gain competitive advantages, and enter new markets. They offer opportunities for expansion and can reshape industries. However, despite their strategic significance, a surprising number of M&A deals fail to deliver the expected benefits. While financial analyses and market evaluations are extensively conducted, it’s often the human side of these transactions that is overlooked. In reality, it’s the people—the employees, management teams, and corporate cultures—that can make or break a merger or acquisition. This article delves into the critical human resource (HR) strategies that go beyond the financials to ensure M&A success.

The Importance of HR in M&A

An organization’s most valuable asset is its people. Yet, during M&A transactions, the focus tends to be on financial metrics, legal considerations, and operational efficiencies, with insufficient attention paid to the human element. Studies have consistently shown that up to 90% of acquisitions fail to achieve their desired outcomes, and a significant factor contributing to this high failure rate is the neglect of people-related issues. Early involvement of HR professionals in the M&A process is crucial to navigate these challenges. By proactively addressing human capital concerns, organizations can mitigate risks and leverage their workforce to drive value creation throughout the transaction.

Key HR Strategies for M&A Success

Early Involvement of HR in the M&A Process

Involving HR professionals from the very beginning of the M&A journey is imperative. HR needs to understand the rationale behind the deal, the strategic objectives, and how the integration is expected to unfold. This early engagement allows HR to identify potential people-related risks and to develop strategies that align with the overall business goals. By being part of the initial discussions, HR can provide valuable insights into cultural compatibility, leadership alignment, and employee retention, which are critical factors in the success of the merger or acquisition.

Talent Assessment and Retention

One of the fundamental steps in ensuring a successful merger or acquisition is the thorough assessment and retention of key talent. This process must extend beyond the executive leadership to include employees at all levels who are essential to the organization’s functioning and future growth. Research indicates that employee turnover in acquired companies can nearly double in the two years following an acquisition. High turnover not only results in the loss of vital knowledge and skills but can also undermine the integration process and disrupt business operations.

Developing effective retention strategies is crucial. This may involve identifying key employees, understanding their motivations and concerns, and offering incentives or career development opportunities to encourage them to stay. Keeping top talent engaged and committed helps maintain continuity and drives performance during a period of significant change.

“Identifying who your key players are and ensuring they feel valued is pivotal during M&A transitions. Without the dedication of these individuals, even the most strategically sound mergers can lose momentum.” – Sherry Godin, Director of Human Resources at Freelandt Caldwell Reilly LLP

Effective Communication

A robust and proactive communication strategy is essential throughout the M&A process. Change can create uncertainty and anxiety among employees, potentially leading to decreased morale and productivity. Clear, transparent, and ongoing communication helps manage expectations, reduces rumors, and fosters trust. It’s important to address how the merger or acquisition will impact employees both professionally and personally from day one.

Effective communication involves more than just initial announcements. It requires continuous updates, opportunities for dialogue, and mechanisms to address employee concerns. By keeping the lines of communication open, organizations can engage their workforce, facilitate smoother transitions, and retain critical talent.

Cultural Alignment

Company culture encompasses the values, beliefs, behaviors, and practices that define how an organization operates. When two companies come together, conflicting corporate cultures can become a significant obstacle. In fact, incompatible cultures are often cited as a primary reason for M&A failures. Early identification of cultural differences is essential. Organizations should conduct cultural assessments to understand the potential challenges and to develop strategies for integrating or aligning cultures.

Aligning cultures doesn’t mean forcing one company’s culture onto another. Instead, it’s about finding common ground, respecting differences, and creating a new, shared culture that supports the goals of the merged entity. Engaging employees in this process can help build a cohesive and motivated workforce, ready to drive the organization forward.

Organizational Alignment

Alongside cultural integration, aligning organizational structures, systems, and processes is critical. Mergers often result in duplications of roles, conflicting systems, and incompatible processes, which can hinder efficiency and performance. Conducting a thorough analysis of the organizational design helps identify opportunities for functional integration and synergies.

Making informed decisions about restructuring, resource allocation, and process harmonization requires careful planning. Prioritizing these actions ensures that the organization can operate effectively post-merger. It also helps in managing workforce adjustments in a fair and transparent manner, which is vital for maintaining employee trust and morale.

Strategic Planning and Prioritization

In the urgency to realize the benefits of a merger or acquisition, organizations may rush into tactical tasks without a clear strategic plan. However, taking the time to map out a comprehensive strategy is vital. This involves identifying critical actions that require immediate attention, those that can be planned for the medium term, and others that can be deferred.

A well-thought-out plan helps avoid inefficiencies, such as redundant efforts or misallocated resources. By establishing clear priorities and sequencing tasks appropriately, organizations can ensure that their efforts are focused on activities that truly drive value and support the overall objectives of the merger or acquisition.

Humanizing the M&A Process

Clarify Objectives

Understanding the underlying reasons for the merger or acquisition helps in shaping strategies and guiding decision-making. Clarity of purpose is essential not only for leadership but also for employees at all levels. Whether the goal is to expand market presence, achieve economies of scale, acquire new technologies, or eliminate competition, aligning objectives among all stakeholders ensures that everyone is working towards the same vision.

Engaging employees in understanding the ‘why’ behind the merger can increase their buy-in and commitment. It helps them see how the changes contribute to the company’s future and their own professional growth, reducing resistance and fostering a positive outlook.

Shared Values and Respect

Merging businesses can be likened to blending families; it’s a process that requires sensitivity, respect, and a focus on shared values. Recognizing and honoring the legacy of each organization fosters goodwill and facilitates cooperation. This is especially important when dealing with employees who may have dedicated many years to the company and feel a strong attachment to its culture and practices.

A human-centered approach that prioritizes empathy can enhance the likelihood of long-term success. This involves acknowledging the emotions and concerns of employees, showing respect for their contributions, and involving them in shaping the future of the merged organization. Such an approach builds trust and loyalty, which are crucial for a successful integration.

Collaborative Approach with Advisors

Navigating the complexities of M&A transactions requires expertise in various domains, including HR, finance, legal, and tax. Working closely with advisors and consultants who specialize in these areas provides valuable insights and strategies. Leveraging professional expertise ensures that decisions are well-informed and aligned with overarching goals.

Engaging with HR consultants, for example, can help in conducting thorough due diligence, developing retention programs, and designing integration plans that are sensitive to cultural nuances. Collaboration with advisors allows organizations to address challenges proactively and optimize outcomes.

Implementing HR Due Diligence

Conducting comprehensive HR due diligence early in the M&A process is critical to identifying potential risks and opportunities related to human capital. This involves analyzing critical HR functions, such as compensation and benefits, employment contracts, compliance issues, and labor relations. It also includes assessing the compatibility of HR policies and practices.

Effective HR due diligence helps prevent obvious pitfalls, such as unexpected liabilities or compliance issues. More importantly, it uncovers opportunities for synergy and value creation. For instance, aligning benefit programs or harmonizing compensation structures can lead to cost savings and enhanced employee satisfaction.

Post-Merger Integration

Change Management

Managing the transition for employees requires intentional and effective change management strategies. This includes addressing workforce adjustments, redefining roles and responsibilities, and implementing new processes. Equipping leaders to guide their teams through the change is essential. Providing training, resources, and support helps employees adapt to new ways of working.

Supporting employees through the change fosters resilience and adaptability. It’s important to recognize that change can be difficult, and individuals may react differently. By proactively managing the change process, organizations can minimize disruptions and maintain productivity.

Ongoing Communication and Engagement

Communication doesn’t end once the merger is completed. Continuous communication and employee engagement are vital post-merger. Keeping employees informed about progress, celebrating milestones, and reinforcing the vision and goals of the combined entity help build trust and align efforts towards shared success.

Soliciting feedback from employees and involving them in decision-making where appropriate increases engagement and ownership. This ongoing dialogue ensures that potential issues are identified early and addressed promptly, contributing to a more cohesive and motivated workforce.

Conclusion

While financial considerations are foundational to mergers and acquisitions, the key to true success lies in effectively managing the human element. Organizations that invest time and resources into strategic HR practices throughout the M&A process position themselves to not only mitigate risks but also to harness the full potential of their people. By focusing on talent retention, cultural alignment, effective communication, and compassionate change management, organizations can achieve the desired outcomes of the merger or acquisition. Ultimately, it’s the people who drive innovation, productivity, and growth, building a solid foundation for sustained success.


About the Expert

Name: Sherry Godin

Title: Director of Human Resources

Email: sgodin@fcrcpa.com

Sherry leads the Human Resources function at Freelandt Caldwell Reilly LLP and provides Human Capital Management consulting through FCR Paradigm. With extensive experience in optimizing human capital across various industries, both domestically and internationally, Sherry specializes in designing customized solutions that foster resilient team cultures and drive operational success.

Let’s Talk!

Call us at 1 855 363 3526 or fill out the form below and we’ll contact you to discuss your specific situation.

  • Topic Name:
  • Should be Empty: