Your Business News
It’s time for a change: “Grandfathered share”
November 17, 2022
Authored by RSM Canada LLP
Gracie Tetzlaff CPA, CA shared this article
ARTICLE | November 17, 2022
Canada’s laws, including the ITA, are constantly changing to reflect the current social and economic environment. Yet one phrase in the Act seems to have escaped this review for almost 35 years.
Since 1988, subsection 248(1) has provided a definition of “grandfathered share,” which is relevant for provisions including the stop-loss rules in subsections 112(3) to (3.32). This term (or its plural) appears 22 times in the Act and is further referenced in subsequent CRA guidance. But the terms “grandfathered” and “grandfathering” are not exclusive to the Act. They are widely used terms among policy makers and are mentioned in our national defence policy, the Elections Canada website, and federal government employment rules, to name a few.
The term “grandfathered,” where used in a legal context, essentially means someone or something that is exempt from a new law or regulation. A grandfather clause (with variants such as “grandfather policy,” “grandfathering,” and “grandfathered in”) is a provision in which an old rule continues to apply to certain existing situations, while a new rule is introduced to apply to all future cases. The term may date back to King Henry II of England, but it is best known today for its roots in America’s racial history—specifically, a set of 19th-century laws regulating voting rights in the United States.
The passing of the 15th amendment to the US constitution in 1870 prohibited racial discrimination in voting but allowed restrictions that were non-racial. As a result, various states created requirements—such as literacy tests, poll taxes, and constitutional quizzes—designed to prevent African-Americans from exercising their newly acquired voting rights. In order for these requirements to not prevent other US citizens from voting, states passed laws to provide an exemption from these requirements for those who could vote (or whose ancestors could vote) prior to the time when African-Americans became eligible to vote. Such rules, most of which were enacted in the early 1890s, became known as “grandfather clauses.” These clauses were struck down by the US Supreme Court in Guinn v. United States (238 US 347 (1915)) in 1915.
Flash forward 130 years and the term continues to be used in various contexts—including tax—despite its segregationist roots.
But there is an additional argument to phase out its use: since 1989, legislative amendments have been drafted in gender-neutral language; words such as “he” and “his” are being replaced with “the taxpayer” and “the taxpayer’s.” Changes are being made despite the fact that they are not legally necessary: section 33(1) of the Interpretation Act provides that “words importing male persons include female persons.” However, the Department of Justice recommends that “gender-specific language should not be used in legislation.”
This latter problem with the term did not escape notice even at the time it was introduced into the Act: tax luminaries Robert Couzin and Robert Dart noted in the 1987 Conference Report that the term was “perhaps inelegant and even sexist.”
Where do we go from here? Although most legislation or policy changes require significant consideration to avoid adverse outcomes, shifting away from the term “grandfathered share” would be a rather simple fix. The term “legacy share” or “exempt share” would still accurately represent the definition in subsection 248(1), while signifying that the legislature is no longer tolerant of the view the original term represents.
A related term is used in the context of life insurance: “Loss of grandfathering” appears in the title to subsection 148(11). Similarly, this could be changed to “Loss of legacy status.”
This content was originally published in the Canadian Tax Foundations newsletter: Canadian Tax Focus. Republished with permission.
Call us at 1 855 363 3526 or fill out the form below and we'll contact you to discuss your specific situation.
This article was written by Sigita Bersenas, Lingzi Layman and originally appeared on 2022-11-17 RSM Canada, and is available online at https://rsmcanada.com/insights/services/business-tax-insights/its-time-for-a-change-grandfathered-shares.html.
The information contained herein is general in nature and based on authorities that are subject to change. RSM Canada guarantees neither the accuracy nor completeness of any information and is not responsible for any errors or omissions, or for results obtained by others as a result of reliance upon such information. RSM Canada assumes no obligation to inform the reader of any changes in tax laws or other factors that could affect information contained herein. This publication does not, and is not intended to, provide legal, tax or accounting advice, and readers should consult their tax advisors concerning the application of tax laws to their particular situations. This analysis is not tax advice and is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for purposes of avoiding tax penalties that may be imposed on any taxpayer.
RSM Canada Alliance provides its members with access to resources of RSM Canada Operations ULC, RSM Canada LLP and certain of their affiliates (“RSM Canada”). RSM Canada Alliance member firms are separate and independent businesses and legal entities that are responsible for their own acts and omissions, and each are separate and independent from RSM Canada. RSM Canada LLP is the Canadian member firm of RSM International, a global network of independent audit, tax and consulting firms. Members of RSM Canada Alliance have access to RSM International resources through RSM Canada but are not member firms of RSM International. Visit rsmcanada.com/aboutus for more information regarding RSM Canada and RSM International. The RSM trademark is used under license by RSM Canada. RSM Canada Alliance products and services are proprietary to RSM Canada.
FCR a proud member of RSM Canada Alliance, a premier affiliation of independent accounting and consulting firms across North America. RSM Canada Alliance provides our firm with access to resources of RSM, the leading provider of audit, tax and consulting services focused on the middle market. RSM Canada LLP is a licensed CPA firm and the Canadian member of RSM International, a global network of independent audit, tax and consulting firms with more than 43,000 people in over 120 countries.
Our membership in RSM Canada Alliance has elevated our capabilities in the marketplace, helping to differentiate our firm from the competition while allowing us to maintain our independence and entrepreneurial culture. We have access to a valuable peer network of like-sized firms as well as a broad range of tools, expertise, and technical resources.
For more information on how FCR can assist you, please call us at 1 855 363 3526